The Thought Occurs

Monday, 6 October 2025

INITIATIVE TO REPLACE GRADING WITH NARRATIVE QUILTING CIRCLES

Event Title: “From Scores to Stories: Weaving the Fabric of Learning”

Location: The Patchwork Pavilion, a renovated sewing room in the Arts Building
Organised by:

  • The Consortium of Communal Creativity

  • Students for Story-Based Assessment

  • The Institute of Embodied Epistemologies
    Ambassador: Auntie Patch, Keeper of the Story Needle


CAMPAIGN SLOGAN:

“Grades divide. Quilts unite.”


OPENING REMARKS: AUNTIE PATCH (she/her)

Master Quilter and Oral Historian

In the old ways, stories are stitched into quilts to remember, to teach, to hold community.
So too must learning be gathered and woven — not sliced into slices of ‘A’ or ‘F’, but wrapped in warmth and conversation.
Each patch is a narrative, each stitch a connection, and the whole cloth is our shared becoming.


THE OLD SYSTEM VS. THE QUILTING CIRCLE

Traditional GradingNarrative Quilting Circle
Individual scoreCommunal story patch
Letter/numberEmotional tone and thematic colours
Summative judgmentContinuous narrative weaving
Ranking studentsCelebrating interwoven journeys
Anxiety and competitionSafe space for vulnerability and growth

PROCESS: THE NARRATIVE QUILTING CIRCLE

  • Students gather weekly in a circle, each bringing a story-patch reflecting on their learning journey.

  • Story-patches may take many forms: spoken word, a poem, a drawing, a song, or a symbolic stitch.

  • A facilitator guides the circle, encouraging listening with heart and honouring diverse rhythms.

  • Together, the circle stitches the patches onto a communal quilt representing the class’s collective learning landscape.


FACULTY TESTIMONIAL: PROFESSOR NYLA THREAD (they/them)

I have witnessed students blossom in ways grades could never capture.
When we quilt together, assessment becomes a living act of empathy, not a cold transaction.


STUDENT REFLECTION: ZIN (they/them)

I used to dread finals. Now I look forward to sharing my story-patch and seeing how it fits into our quilt.
It feels like home.


VISUALS: THE QUILT

  • Vibrant colours representing emotional journeys: blues for moments of doubt, reds for passionate breakthroughs, greens for collaboration and growth.

  • Symbols embroidered for themes like resilience, curiosity, and shared challenges.

  • The quilt travels each semester, displayed in common areas and digital story maps.


ADMINISTRATIVE RESPONSE:

The university pledges to pilot Narrative Quilting Circles in core courses next semester.
Grading rubrics will be reimagined as story guides.
Final exams replaced by “The Gathering” — a festival of shared reflections.


CLOSING RITUAL: THE FINAL STITCH

Students and faculty gather to add the last stitch of the semester, symbolising unity and ongoing growth. As the needle passes, a soft chant arises:

“We are patches, we are threads,
Together we weave where knowledge spreads.”

No comments:

Post a Comment