The Thought Occurs

Monday, 16 November 2026

The University That Was Always Changing

The university had decided that it needed to change.

This was not unusual. The university had been changing for as long as anyone could remember.

It had changed its organisational structure, its administrative structure, its management structure and, on several occasions, the structure responsible for changing the other structures.

Each change had been described as transformational.

The latest transformation was intended to make the university more responsive, more innovative, more efficient and more capable of meeting the challenges of the future.

A consultant was engaged.

After several months of investigation, the consultant delivered a report recommending significant organisational change.

The university accepted the recommendations.

A new organisational structure was announced.

Departments were renamed. Faculties were reorganised. Administrative responsibilities were redistributed. Several offices were merged, while others were divided into smaller offices to ensure greater operational flexibility.

New senior positions were created to oversee the transformation.

The university celebrated the achievement.

It was now better positioned to respond to a rapidly changing environment.

Unfortunately, the transformation had disrupted several existing activities.

Nobody was quite sure who was responsible for approving research expenditure. Teaching arrangements had become temporarily uncertain. Some administrative staff had been transferred to offices whose functions were still being determined.

The university recognised that these difficulties were to be expected during a period of significant change.

A working group was established to manage the transition.

The working group recommended a further review of administrative responsibilities.

The review identified several areas requiring clarification.

A second working group was established.

Meanwhile, the university discovered that the new organisational structure was not sufficiently aligned with its strategic priorities.

A new strategic plan was therefore commissioned.

The strategic plan recommended a more agile organisational structure.

The university was delighted.

It had identified an opportunity to build upon the transformation already underway.

A further restructuring was announced.

Some staff expressed concern that they had only recently adjusted to the previous arrangement.

The university acknowledged their concerns and explained that change was now a permanent feature of the institutional environment.

Staff were encouraged to demonstrate resilience, adaptability and a positive attitude towards continuous improvement.

One academic asked whether the university might occasionally allow things to remain unchanged long enough for people to do their work.

The question was referred to the appropriate committee.

The committee agreed that continuity was important.

However, continuity should not be confused with resistance to change.

It recommended the establishment of a new initiative to promote a culture of continuous transformation.

The recommendation was approved.

The university was pleased to announce that the initiative had been successfully implemented.

There was now considerable momentum behind the change programme.

The university had become more agile.

It could reorganise itself more quickly than ever before.

Indeed, it had become so agile that nobody could be certain what it would look like by the end of the year.

Academics continued to teach, research and supervise students, although some were finding it increasingly difficult to identify the administrative arrangements under which they were expected to do so.

The university reassured them that these matters would be resolved in due course.

In the meantime, a new transformation strategy was being prepared.

It would build on the lessons learned from previous transformations while recognising that the university must never become complacent about its capacity to change.

The university was confident that this time the transformation would be different.

It had, after all, learned a great deal from all the transformations that had preceded it.

The only thing that had not changed was the need for another transformation.

Monday, 9 November 2026

The University That Measured Everything Except What Mattered

The university had always valued academic excellence.

Unfortunately, excellence was difficult to demonstrate.

Some academics produced excellent research without generating sufficient evidence of excellence. Others generated excellent evidence without producing research.

The university recognised that this represented an inconsistency in its performance-management framework.

A committee was therefore established to investigate the relationship between academic excellence and the documentation of academic excellence.

The committee met regularly.

At its first meeting, members agreed that excellence should be measurable.

At its second meeting, they agreed that the existing measures did not adequately capture excellence.

At its third meeting, they agreed that a more comprehensive framework was required.

The committee's recommendations were unanimously approved.

The university introduced a new system for measuring academic excellence.

Teaching was measured.

Research was measured.

Engagement was measured.

Collegiality was measured.

The time spent measuring these activities was measured in turn.

Academics were required to demonstrate their contribution to institutional excellence through a series of performance indicators.

The indicators were carefully designed to ensure that excellence could be identified, quantified, compared, and reported.

The university was pleased with the results.

Academic excellence had increased substantially.

The evidence was conclusive.

Every academic had now been assessed.

There remained, however, a minor difficulty.

Some academics continued to produce excellent research without adequately satisfying the requirements of the assessment system.

The committee reconvened.

It concluded that the problem was not with the research but with the visibility of the research.

A new initiative was introduced to improve the visibility of academic excellence.

Academics were encouraged to document their achievements more comprehensively.

Workshops were organised.

Guidelines were distributed.

A dedicated administrative office was established to support the process.

The university's reporting requirements were revised.

The results were impressive.

The number of documented research outputs increased.

The number of completed performance assessments increased.

The number of academics demonstrating compliance increased.

The university announced that it had achieved its target for academic excellence.

One academic asked whether the quality of the research had improved.

The committee considered the question.

It agreed that research quality was important.

However, research quality was not currently included in the relevant performance indicator.

The committee therefore recommended that research quality should be considered in the next review of the framework.

The recommendation was approved.

The university was delighted.

It had successfully established a system in which every academic activity could be measured, every measurement could be reported, and every report could demonstrate institutional progress.

The committee was congratulated on its achievement.

Its members were invited to participate in a new initiative examining the relationship between performance measurement and institutional excellence.

The initiative was expected to generate significant opportunities for further development.

Meanwhile, the academics continued their work.

Some taught students.

Some conducted research.

Some wrote papers.

Some supervised doctoral candidates.

Occasionally, one of them produced something that changed the way people understood the world.

Unfortunately, these activities did not always generate the required documentation.

The university recognised that this represented a continuing challenge.

A new committee was established.

Its terms of reference included the development of appropriate measures for identifying activities that mattered but had not yet been measured.

The committee's first meeting was scheduled for the following month.

The university was confident that the matter would be resolved.

After all, everything that mattered was now being measured.

And everything that was measured mattered.

The university had only to determine which was which.

Monday, 2 November 2026

THE ACADEMIC ANIMAL A Natural History of Tertiary Education Episode VIII — Migration and Speciation

The young academic has now left the nest.

It has learned to hunt.

It has acquired a territory.

It has survived the attentions of reviewers.

And, after several years of increasingly independent behaviour, it has finally become an adult.

The next stage is inevitable.

It must migrate.


The First Migration

Migration begins innocently enough.

The young academic attends a conference.

It visits another university.

It takes a postdoctoral position.

It joins a research project.

Perhaps it spends six months in another department.

Perhaps it moves to another country.

The stated reason is usually professional.

The ecological significance is greater.

The animal has entered a new habitat.

Here it encounters unfamiliar specimens.

They use different words.

They cite different ancestors.

They consider different questions important.

And, most disturbingly, they appear to have perfectly good reasons for doing so.


Habitat Shock

The first response is often defensive.

The migrating animal observes that the new population has misunderstood several things.

Its terminology is peculiar.

Its categories are unnecessarily complicated.

Its methods are questionable.

Its literature is incomplete.

Its assumptions are obvious.

The animal may spend several months explaining these deficiencies to colleagues.

Then something happens.

It begins to understand them.

This is known as habitat acquisition.

The migrant has discovered that what initially appeared to be an eccentric local adaptation may actually be a response to a different intellectual environment.


The Second Vocabulary

The most visible sign of successful migration is linguistic.

The animal begins to acquire a new vocabulary.

At first, it uses the new terms ironically.

Then cautiously.

Then fluently.

Eventually, it finds itself using them in its own work.

This can be unsettling.

The animal has not abandoned its original population.

It has acquired a second academic accent.

Researchers call this lexical hybridisation.

The phenomenon is common among interdisciplinary animals.

It can also cause considerable confusion at dinner parties.


The Mixed Population

Eventually, some animals become capable of moving between habitats without fully belonging to either.

They speak one population's language to another population.

They translate.

They compare.

They notice that two groups have been asking related questions using entirely different vocabularies.

These animals are often described as boundary organisms.

They occupy the spaces between established territories.

The established populations are uncertain what to do with them.

They may be regarded as:

innovative,

confused,

interdisciplinary,

undisciplined,

visionary,

or “interesting.”

The classification depends largely on who is speaking.


The Hybrid

Sometimes the migrant brings something back.

A method.

A distinction.

A concept.

A way of asking questions.

The imported trait is combined with an inherited one.

Something new emerges.

The animal itself may not immediately recognise what has happened.

It may simply report:

“I was interested in whether these two approaches might be brought into dialogue.”

Researchers call this hybridisation.

The resulting offspring can be unstable.

It may not fit comfortably into any existing disciplinary territory.

But instability is not necessarily a disadvantage.

It can create new ecological niches.


The New Territory

Eventually, the hybrid begins to attract other animals.

They share its interests.

They learn its vocabulary.

They cite its papers.

They attend its conferences.

A small population forms.

At first, it is described as a perspective.

Then an approach.

Then a framework.

Eventually, someone proposes that it is a field.

This is a critical evolutionary moment.

For once a population has a field, it can have journals.

Once it has journals, it can have conferences.

Once it has conferences, it can have keynote speakers.

And once it has keynote speakers, it is officially alive.


Disciplinary Speciation

Researchers call the process disciplinary speciation.

It occurs when a population becomes sufficiently differentiated from its ancestral population that members of the two groups no longer participate in intellectual life in quite the same way.

They may continue to read one another.

They may continue to disagree.

They may even continue to attend the same conferences.

But they now possess different maps of relevance.

They ask different questions.

They notice different anomalies.

They have different standards of evidence.

And, increasingly, they find one another's work difficult to understand.

The species has diverged.


The Journal Barrier

One of the clearest signs of speciation is the appearance of a new journal.

At first, the journal has difficulty attracting submissions.

Then a few papers appear.

Then more.

The journal develops a readership.

A citation pattern emerges.

Soon the animals begin saying:

“This is really a question for our field.”

The phrase is highly diagnostic.

A new species has probably formed.


The Conference Lek

The new population also develops a characteristic gathering place.

It may be a conference.

The animals migrate from their various habitats and gather in large numbers.

There they display their plumage.

They exchange calls.

They compare territories.

They inspect potential mates and collaborators.

They announce conceptual innovations.

They remember who has cited whom.

The event may last several days.

At its conclusion, most animals return home exhausted but strangely reassured that their population still exists.


Speciation by Distinction

Sometimes the new species is created by a single distinction.

One animal observes:

“Perhaps we need to distinguish between A and B.”

The distinction initially seems modest.

But it reorganises the conceptual habitat.

Others adopt it.

A literature grows around it.

The distinction becomes foundational.

Eventually, an entire population is organised around something that, a generation earlier, nobody had thought required distinguishing.

This is one of the most powerful mechanisms in academic evolution.

A distinction does not merely describe a territory.

It can create one.


The Naming Event

Every new species requires a name.

The naming process can take considerable time.

Candidates include:

Critical X Studies.

The New X.

Post-X.

Neo-X.

X and Beyond.

Trans-X.

Or, increasingly:

X Ecologies.

The final choice is important.

A good name must distinguish the population from its ancestors without making the relationship to them entirely incomprehensible.

The animal must be new.

But not so new that nobody knows what funding category to put it in.


Reproductive Isolation

Once a field becomes established, something curious occurs.

The population begins to reproduce itself.

Students are trained within the new vocabulary.

Supervisors introduce them to the canonical literature.

Journals publish work using the characteristic distinctions.

Conferences reinforce the shared map.

The new species now has its own reproductive system.

At this point, the original mutation has become inheritance.


The Paradox of Innovation

This creates one of the great paradoxes of academic evolution.

A field often begins by challenging established ways of seeing.

But once successful, it develops its own established ways of seeing.

The rebellious population acquires traditions.

The radical distinction becomes canonical.

The critique becomes methodology.

The innovation becomes curriculum.

The outsider becomes an authority.

Eventually, young animals are taught that the field was once revolutionary.

This is usually true.

It is simply no longer revolutionary.


The Return Migration

Not all migration is permanent.

Some animals return to their original habitat.

But they do not return unchanged.

They carry foreign conceptual material with them.

Their colleagues notice.

“That’s not how we usually think about it.”

The returning animal smiles.

It has heard this before.

The new distinction is explained.

At first, resistance is strong.

Then someone realises that the imported idea is useful.

Another animal adopts it.

A paper is written.

A seminar is organised.

The distinction spreads.

The original habitat has changed.

Migration has become ecological exchange.


Extinction

Speciation also carries risks.

Some populations fail.

Their journals disappear.

Their conferences shrink.

Their terminology ceases to circulate.

Their students move elsewhere.

Eventually, the field becomes a historical curiosity.

This is disciplinary extinction.

It is not necessarily caused by the ideas being false.

A population may simply lose its reproductive capacity.

No students.

No journals.

No funding.

No institutional habitat.

Without reproduction, even a perfectly good idea can disappear.


The Fossil Record

Extinct academic species do, however, leave traces.

Old books.

Forgotten terminology.

Footnotes.

Department names.

Archived journals.

Occasionally, a young academic discovers one.

The old idea is examined.

Something in it appears strangely familiar.

The young animal begins to use it again.

The extinct species has not quite returned.

But one of its characteristics has.

Researchers call this conceptual re-emergence.

The academic habitat is full of such fossils.

Some have been waiting decades to become useful again.


The Great Migration

From the perspective of the entire university, the movement of individuals between habitats produces a continual exchange of conceptual material.

Animals migrate.

Ideas migrate with them.

Distinctions cross boundaries.

Methods hybridise.

New populations form.

Old ones adapt.

Some disappear.

Others become dominant.

The academic ecosystem is therefore never still.

Its apparent stability conceals constant movement.


What Actually Migrates?

Yet the most interesting thing that migrates is not a theory.

It is not even a concept.

It is a way of noticing.

An animal trained in one habitat carries its habits of attention into another.

There, those habits encounter unfamiliar possibilities.

Some are discarded.

Some survive.

Some combine with foreign ones.

And occasionally, a new pattern of attention emerges.

The animal now sees something that neither population had seen before.


The Speciation Principle

Field researchers have therefore proposed a further principle:

When a population acquires a sufficiently different way of noticing, it may eventually require a different map of the world.

The map then acquires institutions.

The institutions acquire territories.

The territories acquire inhabitants.

The inhabitants train juveniles.

The juveniles inherit the map.

And what began as a small variation in attention becomes a discipline.


The sun is setting over the university.

Across the campus, animals are returning from their various migrations.

Some head back to established nests.

Some cross invisible territorial boundaries.

Some carry unfamiliar vocabulary.

Some are founding new populations.

And somewhere, in a seminar room, a young academic has just made a distinction that nobody had thought to make before.

There is a silence.

An older animal leans forward.

“That’s interesting.”

The juvenile waits.

The adult continues:

“Has anyone done that before?”

The hunt begins again.

A new territory is opening.

And, somewhere in the distance, the first calls of a new species can already be heard.


The Academic Animal — Series Conclusion

But the story is not quite over.

For the university does not merely contain academic animals.

It is itself the environment that shapes them.

The habitat determines what can flourish.

The adults determine what the young learn to notice.

The territories determine what counts as relevant.

The hunt determines what is worth finding.

The nest determines what is reproduced.

And migration determines what can become different.

Perhaps, then, the strangest discovery in this natural history is not that academics behave like animals.

It is that animals behave like academics.

They inhabit worlds structured by inherited distinctions.

They learn what matters from one another.

They reproduce ways of seeing.

They establish territories.

They compete.

They cooperate.

They migrate.

And sometimes, quite accidentally, they change the world they have learned to inhabit.

The academic animal is therefore not merely a creature that lives in a university.

It is a creature that reproduces a university wherever it goes.

Field researchers are currently investigating whether this process can ever be stopped.

Early results are inconclusive.

Several committees have been formed.

Further research is required.